Who You Are Is Where You Are: Brain or Heart?

Whether people locate their sense of self in the brain or the heart can have a major influence on people’s decision-making, according to a new study by management and business experts at Rice University and Columbia University.

Overall, the study found people tend to locate the self in the brain.

The paper, “Who You Are Is Where You Are: Antecedents and Consequences of Locating the Self in the Brain or the Heart,” will be published in the journal Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.

“We view our research as a first step toward reviving the debate about which part of our body contains the seat of the self – a debate that dates back to the ancient Greek philosophers,” said Hajo Adam, an assistant professor of management at Rice’s Jones Graduate School of Business. “Our findings demonstrate not only that the preference for the brain versus the heart as the location of the self systematically depends on a person’s self-construal — meaning the perceptions that individuals have about their thoughts, feelings and actions in relation to others — but also that the location of the self has important implications for people’s opinions on contentious medical issues as well as prosocial contributions.”

Adam co-authored the paper with Otilia Obodaru, an assistant professor of management at the Jones School, and Adam Galinsky, the Vikram S. Pandit Professor of Business and chair of the management division at Columbia’s business school.

The authors’ research consisted of eight studies exploring the antecedents and consequences of whether people locate their sense of self in the brain or the heart. Their hypothesis was that although people generally tend to locate their sense of self in the brain, this preference is significantly stronger for people with an independent self-construal than for people with an interdependent self-construal.

People with an independent self-construal tend to assert the autonomous nature of the self, realize their internal attributes and influence their environment. In pursuit of these self-relevant goals, these people often engage in thoughts, conversations and behaviors that are conceptually related to the brain. In contrast, people with an interdependent self-construal tend to be part of a group, maintain harmonious relationships and adjust to others. In pursuit of these self-relevant goals, these people often engage in thoughts, conversations and behaviors that are conceptually related not only to the brain, but also to the heart.

Participant groups ranged in size from 95 to 156 people between the ages of 20 and 40; about half the participants were women and half were men. The majority of participants were Americans. The study included a group of Indians, a cultural group that tends to have interdependent self-construals.

In the first study, participants were told that a person’s identity and sense of self are an essential feature of people’s humanity, and that the researchers were interested in finding out where the sense of self is located. The authors explained that some areas or parts of the body may seem more or less connected to the sense of self, so they asked participants to indicate which part of their body is most connected to their sense of who they are. In the next studies, the authors sought to probe participants’ perception of where the self is located more subtly to provide convergent evidence across a variety of measures and underscore the robustness of the effect.

In the first six studies, participants’ self-construals consistently influenced the location of the self: The general preference for locating the self in the brain was more enhanced among men than women and among Americans than Indians; participants primed with an independent self-construal also were more likely to say their self is in the brain. In all six studies, the majority of participants located the self in the brain rather than the heart, but this behavior was diminished among women, Indians and participants primed with an interdependent self-construal. In the seventh study, participants’ perceived location of the self influenced their judgments of controversial medical issues such as the legal definition of death and abortion legislation.

In the final study, the authored primed participants to locate the self in the brain or the heart, which influenced how much effort they put into writing a support letter for and how much money they donated to a charity for a brain disease (Alzheimer’s disease) or a heart disease (coronary artery disease). For example, people who believed that the brain contains the self contributed more than twice as much money to a charity fighting Alzheimer’s than people who believed that the heart contains the self. The reverse pattern also held true: People who believed that the heart contains the self contributed more than twice as much money to a charity fighting heart attacks than people who believed that the brain contains the self.

“These results suggest that where people locate the self might be a notable characteristic that shapes people’s psychological processes and decision-making,” said Obodaru. “Consequently, there may be great value in better understanding the antecedents and consequences of being a ‘brain person’ or a ‘heart person.'”

The study’s findings also suggest that leadership speeches, entrepreneurial pitches or marketing materials that invoke the heart or the brain could be differentially persuasive, depending on the recipient’s perceived location of the self, the author said. For example, the results suggest that advertising messages targeted at people with independent self-construals compared with messages targeted at people with interdependent self-construals might be more effective if they invoke the brain rather than the heart. (For example, “Your head tells you: Buying this car is the right decision” versus “Your heart tells you: Buying this car is the right decision.”)

[Editor’s note: we post this here for informational purposes and perhaps to get people thinking – am I being driven into one or the other? Energy practitioners also recognize that self-identification and Will reside in the Solar Plexus Chakra which is in the gut area – and now we know how much the gut affects brain and behavior. However, the heart region is equally recognized. In Chinese medicine brain problems often have their origin in the heart which is necessary for blood and oxygen. Others recognize that all of you is contained in each and every cell of your body. And still others believe the mind is not in the brain but in the body in such areas as fascial tissue.-HC]

For a copy of the study, e-mail [email protected]. For more information about Adam and Obodaru’s research, visit the Jones School’s website: http://business.rice.edu/JGSB2011_2Column.aspx?id=4294975023.

Follow the Jones School via Twitter @RiceMBA.

Illustration by: Sapna Khandwala, Public Library of Science [CC BY 2.5], via Wikimedia Commons